Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on LinkedIn

Business partners in Texas do not automatically have a right of first refusal when another owner wants to sell their interest. A right of first refusal typically arises from a partnership agreement, company agreement, shareholder agreement, or another enforceable contractual provision. Without such a provision, the owner’s ability to sell depends on the business structure, governing documents, and applicable Texas law.

For Dallas-Fort Worth business owners, a proposed sale can raise questions about ownership, control, and whether an unfamiliar investor may acquire an interest in the company.

Key Takeaways

  • Texas law does not automatically give partners a right of first refusal.
  • A right of first refusal generally comes from a written agreement.
  • Selling an economic interest does not necessarily transfer management rights.
  • Violating a first refusal provision can lead to litigation.
  • Clear transfer restrictions can help prevent ownership disputes.

What Is a Right of First Refusal in a Business Partnership?

A right of first refusal (ROFR) gives an existing owner or another designated party the opportunity to purchase an ownership interest before the seller completes a qualifying transaction with an outside buyer. The right is typically triggered by a third-party offer the seller intends to accept, although the agreement may establish different triggering events.

For example, suppose two partners own a Dallas construction company. One receives an offer from an outside investor to purchase their ownership interest for $400,000. If their agreement contains a right of first refusal, the selling partner may have to present the offer to the other partner and allow them to purchase the interest on the same terms before completing the outside sale. The agreement determines how the right operates, including deadlines, notice requirements, and whether the existing owner must specifically match the outside offer.

Can a Partner Sell Their Ownership Interest Without Permission?

Sometimes. Texas law distinguishes between transferring an economic interest and giving another person the right to participate in managing the business.

In a general partnership, a partner may generally transfer their economic interest, such as the right to receive distributions, without automatically making the buyer a partner. Admission as a partner ordinarily requires consent under applicable law and the partnership agreement.

Limited liability companies have similar distinctions between an ownership interest’s economic rights and membership or management rights.

The governing documents may impose additional transfer restrictions. As a result, a proposed sale does not necessarily confer on the buyer voting authority or control over the company’s operations.

What Happens if a Partner Violates a Right of First Refusal?

When an owner sells an interest without honoring an enforceable right of first refusal, the affected party may have grounds for a breach of contract claim.

The available remedies depend on the agreement, the transaction, and whether the sale has already closed.

For example, a partner who discovers that an ownership interest was transferred without the required notice may seek damages. In appropriate circumstances, the partner might also seek an injunction or specific performance to enforce the contractual right of purchase.

Courts examine the language of the agreement and whether the claimant complied with the conditions required to exercise the right.

How Does a Right of First Refusal Differ From a Buy-Sell Agreement?

A right of first refusal and a buy-sell agreement address related but different ownership issues.

A right of first refusal typically becomes relevant when an owner receives an outside offer and wants to sell.

A buy-sell agreement can establish broader procedures for transferring ownership when certain events occur, such as retirement, death, disability, termination of employment, or a serious disagreement between owners.

Buy-sell provisions may establish valuation methods, payment arrangements, and circumstances under which an owner must offer or sell their interest.

A business can include both types of provisions in its governing documents, provided their terms work together.

Can a Right of First Refusal Prevent an Outside Investor From Becoming an Owner?

A right of first refusal can give existing owners an opportunity to purchase an interest before an outside party proceeds with a transaction. However, it does not necessarily prohibit outside ownership.

If the existing owners decline to exercise their rights, the seller may be permitted to proceed with the proposed sale, subject to contractual restrictions.

Businesses concerned about control should also consider how their agreements address admission of new owners, voting rights, and transfers to competitors. Those provisions can be particularly important in closely held companies where ownership changes may affect daily operations.

What Should a Right of First Refusal Clause Include?

A poorly drafted provision can create disputes over whether the selling owner followed the proper procedure.

A clear agreement should address:

  • Which ownership transfers trigger the right
  • How the selling owner must provide notice
  • What information must accompany an outside offer
  • How long existing owners have to respond
  • Whether the purchase terms must match the third-party offer
  • What happens if multiple owners exercise the right
  • When the seller may complete an outside sale

The agreement should also address transfers involving gifts, family members, trusts, or related entities, where appropriate.

When an Ownership Sale Becomes a Legal Dispute

An ownership transfer can change the direction of a business, particularly when the remaining owners disagree about who should acquire an interest or whether the sale was permitted. Ryan G. Cole Law, PLLC represents Dallas-Fort Worth businesses and owners in partnership and shareholder disputes. If another owner is selling an interest without honoring your contractual rights, or your proposed sale is being challenged, connect with us today.

About the Author
Ryan G. Cole is a seasoned legal professional and the driving force behind Ryan G. Cole Law, PLLC, a boutique firm specializing in commercial litigation and construction law. Based in McKinney, Texas, his practice extends across the Dallas-Fort Worth area and northern Texas, where he offers experience in areas such as business and construction disputes, contract and agreement matters, intellectual property, transactions, arbitration, and litigation. With a wealth of experience in both prosecuting and defending commercial litigation cases, Ryan has successfully navigated numerous legal battles, including arbitration cases and proceedings in state and federal courts in Texas and Oklahoma. A keen listener, he prioritizes understanding his clients' concerns and works diligently to reduce risk and bolster businesses by proactively addressing legal issues. Ryan G. Cole is dedicated to crafting tailored strategies that align with each client's needs and objectives. He is committed to providing astute legal counsel and skillful representation, with a strong focus on cost-effectiveness and personalized attention, ensuring the best possible outcomes for his clients.